How Much (community? time? resources?) is Too Much?

I wrote this in response to Julie’s recent April Ask where she asked “How do you think anxiously awaiting final numbers each month feels for Lace?”

I know a piece of how it feels for Lace each month because she tells us.  She tells us it feels like an indictment on her when the numbers are low.  She tells us that she is sometimes afraid she made a mistake to retire – because of the “what if’s” that are a result of the unreliability of white folks.  She tells us that at times the fears are a barrier to her creative flow and at other times, she has to adopt a “fuck it” attitude, because she knows she is doing what is right.  And yet, that fuck it attitude can only last so long, before fear or anxiety grow once again.

I would love for Lace’s income to always be assured; and for the organization to not only meet all of our current commitments but to expand and grow in the ways that we serve others.  I’m sure many of the other regular sustainers here long for that as well.  To my knowledge, we don’t have anyone in the community with the means to single handedly make that happen.

As a community though, we are powerful.  I wonder sometimes what the lurkers who don’t engage (financially or otherwise) are thinking. 

Before finding this community, my view of community has often been something along the lines of “oh, someone else will respond to that question / meet that need.”  Community in the past for me has often meant a way to pull away from people.  The larger the community, the easier I can hide there.  I will get “credit” for my attendance and yet have no responsibility at all.

When it comes to this community at Lace on Race, if I can comfortably read here about budget deficits and shortfalls and still think “someone else will meet that need” – what drives that?

Lace has said it’s because we don’t want her living *too* well.  I used to think that wasn’t it.  How could that be it?  But the more I ponder this unhealthy idea of community where I can become calloused as I assume others are stepping up already, the more I realize what Lace says IS at the root of that. 

When we think as a society about meeting the needs of others, we always think in terms of ‘enough’.  What is enough?  How much is too much?  If I can see from the comments that at least x number of people are responding to the asks, I can assume that the org is getting “enough” (as defined by my comfort).  Why should I sacrifice?  Wouldn’t Lace then have “too much”?

That’s the wrong view from so many angles.  If I’m speaking from a competitive stance in not wanting Lace to do better than I am financially, I’m wielding a tool of white supremacy.  If I’m holding myself apart from the work that this community is doing by thinking the engagement of others is enough, I’m wielding my individuality as a tool of white supremacy.  I can dehumanize Lace by either putting her on a pedestal, confident she can work miracles even with just a piece of her budget, or by holding her or her work as ‘less than’ and thinking whatever she gets is definitely plenty – rather than desiring to walk alongside my friend and mentor and work and walk together.

This is what we get with white supremacy.  Competition, individualism, manipulations and maneuvers – always trying to get ahead.  I wonder what it takes to get buy-in?  To get people who aren’t yet in that place to see that *each thread* is needed to weave the complete tapestry.  To see that our potential as a community only increases as we begin to move together and bring ourselves to the table.

I hope that as we live out community boldly and beautifully here – eyes always focused on our North and Western Stars, that you who are watching in the shadows will see this and want to experience true community as well.

Return to (or join us in) the Bistro for discussion!


8 responses to “How Much (community? time? resources?) is Too Much?”

  1. Danielle Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Holcombe

    Last message from me before I hear from you again Rebecca. Would you be able to take your next reply to the Bistro instead? The link to the Bistro discussion is in the very last line. Lace often says the work is in the comments, but the Bistro is where we are trying to drive folks and conversation flows much more smoothly there. Thanks!

  2. Danielle Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Holcombe

    And Rebecca, it’s late for me on the East Coast so I’m going to bed now. Would you be willing to read the article again. I know I wrote it so clearly I know what I meant, but while I can see several other themes in what I wrote, I’m simply not seeing where you are seeing it as a piece on how hard it is to run this space. Can you help me see it through your eyes I guess?

    I’ll check in tomorrow. Have a good night!

  3. Danielle Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Holcombe

    Don’t worry about the name. While I don’t go by joy, it is indeed my name and I try to embrace it in all parts of my life. I appreciated the reminder. 🙂

    And no, I really wasn’t talking about how hard it is to run the space. I’m going to reread and try to find where I may have conveyed that.

    Here is a link to one of our recent newsletters that might answer some of your financial questions. You can do a search on the website for newsletter and find some of the past ones as well, although most have been posted on Facebook and were not also posted here.
    https://laceonrace.com/2021/02/18/lace-on-race-newsletter/?no_frame=1

  4. Rebecca Behar Avatar
    Rebecca Behar

    Dear Danielle (Joy) Holcombe,
    I’m sorry I referred to you as Joy, above. I seemed to remember you by your middle name. I thought you were trying to convey how difficult it is to run this website, do the partnering with other groups and all of the various kinds of outreach, as well as fund the comfort resources for Black and Brown women. Did I get it?
    Since I’ve arrived I have engaged monthly. In another post, I asked some questions about the engagements. Are there levels? Is there a wish list kind of thing of projects LaceonRace is working to fund? Is this group a non-profit? What are the different funding sources? Is it all private individual donations? What does the board do? Are they volunteers? Is the whole group volunteering? I have no problem paying Lace or you all as her team, for the effort, the content creation, any labor you all do, to make this space and praxis possible.
    It seems like the damage done by Holly(?) was pretty devastating and ruined participant’s trust in the organization. Also, it seems like some folks that find this group and sign on, don’t have follow through, or don’t take the time to understand what is expected of them. The point has been well made in a few different posts about taking, consuming from Black Women’s labor and not reimbursing them for the work they have done.
    My comment about sharing other places where I support/engage was just to give a picture of the actions I’ve taken prior to finding, and engaging in this group. It may have come off as self aggrandizing. I could see how it might. I wasn’t trying to brag or congratulate myself. I simply wondered if other engagements would be of interest. I can really see how it doesn’t solve the problem of the short fall for operations. I’m sorry if that was hurtful. I meant no harm, but if I offended I apologize, sincerely.
    You were asking this community to step up and participate in “making it go” – you were asking us to take responsibility. That is my understanding.

  5. Danielle Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Holcombe

    What would the purpose of the list be? Or maybe I should ask you instead what you felt I was asking of the community in post?

  6. Danielle Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Holcombe

    Hi Rebecca,
    Have you read much that Lace has written about financial engagement? You and I certainly have talked before about the ways we here at Lace on Race talk about financial engagement. If you feel like you are “helping” Lace, or the team, what are you helping us to do?

  7. Rebecca Behar Avatar
    Rebecca Behar

    Dear Joy, I can be more specific about the actions I’m taking to combat racism. If you are wanting something less, general than the comment above. Where I’m putting my time energy and financial resources.

  8. Rebecca Behar Avatar
    Rebecca Behar

    Well written. I hear the stress and strain the financial uncertainty. It sounds exhausting. I will help each month, as much as I can. Is there any source of financial support that isn’t individual engagement? Grant writing?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *