When We Demand Comfort

White violence.

What images does that elicit? What circumstances come to mind?

Are you included in any of them?

I doubt it, simply because it takes cognitive effort to recognize how we as white people are armed with violent weapons in our every day thoughts, actions, and communications.

I want to think I am different from “those people” who commit atrocities.

Question, is it more atrocious to kill someone quickly or slowly? Because we are suffocating Black people.

Which leads me to sharing this video by Sterling K. Brown.

I share this carefully. I don’t share it so we white people can steal the pain for ourselves and cry/feel heartbreak/grieve what isn’t ours to grieve. Hear me, please.

If you feel that welling up of emotion and dare to focus only on your empathy (something I question that we as white people can even truly and fully have for the experience of “wearing a mask” as described here), you are doing nothing to make this world a place for BIPOC *for especially Black people* to live and breathe freely.

Our emotional reaction is far too often where it stops.

If my heart “breaks” at this, then I better be fully prepared to also hold the mild twinges of discomfort when my privilege, my racism, my power over is confronted and called out. If I dare grieve for what is lost, then I better be fully prepared to lose my own comfort and safety to make sure this never happens again.

If I look into his eyes with a thought of helping, I surely must be ready and willing to recognize and do the work with myself, my children, my friends, my family, my white peers to disarm ourselves. I better be ready to tend to my own dirt before I demand a better world where love abounds.

And I better be ready to stand by my claimed belief that Black people matter. If the narrative presented to us shifts (and oh, we know that it will because we are always finding reasons to deny Black people humanity), our backpedaling of support is a suffocating mask. If I am only reactive to stories that feel outrageous enough to me, then I am focused on my emotions/guilt, as well as keeping parameters for determining someones humanity.

White violence is complacency. White violence is unaccountability. White violence is volatility. White violence is distancing myself from the problem.

Love is conviction. Love is accountability. Love is mitigating harm. Love is recognizing that the harm starts right at home, in my own heart.

Again, I hesitate, because even in this I am taking Black pain and finding my own learning in it. This is still consumption. It can still be me finding a narrative that suits my complacency.

So, I am asking that as you watch this fellow white people, hold on to your emotions, your immediate reactions, your desire to quell the discomfort. Listen. Reflect. Then, change.

If we won’t, then we are as violently armed as a white man with guns.


5 responses to “When We Demand Comfort”

  1. Anita Slusser Avatar
    Anita Slusser

    I have taught countless numbers of young adults of different colors, genders, cultural backgrounds, educational backgrounds, socio-economic backgrounds, and sexual orientations. I have given them high fives, fist bumps, and hugs on occasion. As a writing instructor, I have had the privilege to read about their experiences of abuse, fear, frustration, and triumph. I have had the privilege to listen to their stories, see their tears, walk them across campus to mental health professionals, hold their hands as they come out to me, thank me, and occasionally express anger and frustration towards me. I am privileged to have them trust me enough to listen to them while simultaneously not being qualified to offer advice or judge anything other than their writing. I have been privileged to see their kindness toward one another and towards me. I don’t say this for any other reason than to express my gratitude for the the privileges of my life and a wish to examine my interactions and do better for my black students to love them better. I want to know how to love them better because I know there are still masks between us. This will take introspection, self reflection, and an active effort to seek out the stories of race both beautiful and uncomfortable, study them, share them and recognize where I am part of the problem.

  2. Kathy Kratchmer Avatar
    Kathy Kratchmer

    Listen….
    Listen again….deeply…

    Reflect…..over hours and days…

    Remember….. this is why I want to make the world safer for Black people…..it’s wrong on every level that survival in the US requires the mask Mr Brown describes… and countless other accommodations to white people…every single day….

    I will keep walking and I, with the help of this community, will change, so help me God.

  3. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    The utter weariness in his voice and eyes does just really strike home. It feels like there aren’t enough places where his tired feet, and the tired feet of all black Americans, can stand. White people have built and constrained all of the spaces, and we just aren’t safe for our fellow humans. And I am a part of, not apart from, that fact. Nothing I do here with Lace and community gets tattooed on my forehead for all to see. I don’t get a safe white lady badge I can wear out and about. Because it’s not going to ever be completely true.

    I’ll try to keep bearing good fruit. That’s how I can be known, the only way. It isn’t enough on my own. But I’m not on my own. And I’ve got work to do with y’all.

  4. Heather S Avatar
    Heather S

    The very first thing that came to mind was a picture from Michigan where it shows a white male protester yelling while standing in front of police officers. That man has no idea how wrapped in privilege he is. The thing is, neither do I. I watched this video earlier this week and cried along, but I’ve just watched a second time and put a hold on any emotions I might feel. This second viewing makes me think he has his mask on even while making this video.

  5. Varda L Avatar
    Varda L

    When watching this, his audience was his Black friends and family. The purpose of this video was to put into words his experience- a common experience- and to educate his circle on how to contextualize this murder. I am grateful for the fact that I’m able to watch and listen to his words. I watched his movements and expressions to understand what it looks like when a Black man is having to appease me in order to create a bridge. That half smile. I heard how my interactions with my coworkers have harmed them. I need to be the person doing the appeasing. I need to build the bridge. I need to stop taking people’s cooperation for granted.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *