A Quiet Word

A quiet message to the community.

Some of you have wondered why we do the the Asks and have questioned where the money goes. After all, it’s just a bunch of memes and musings, right?

I want to be plain. While I am willing to answer this question, I want to be clear that I am by no means obligated to do so, any more than Tim Wise or Robin D’Angelo or Jane Elliot are obligated.

Why activists of color, particularly Black activists, still more specifically Black women activists, are scrutinized and held to a higher standard when it comes to justifying our worth, but are considered less than worthy when it comes to what we produce, even if people consume it regularly, is a question that has an answer, and it is an unsavory one.

We won’t burrow too deeply into those rabbit holes today.

What I will say is that it takes more than you know to bring this to you.

A lot of you are new (we picked up a net gain of 200 over this last month. Welcome.), and are still wading in, so you might not have seen the posts about financial engagement, and why that engagement is crucial for the health of this community, and is also a no less crucial element of your everyday praxis.

Don’t worry. Even seasoned walkers here balk at the idea of financial engagement; fewer than 10 percent do so.

Probably, at least in part, because of the original query above.

So, I will give some detail, but also, for the sake of my own liberation, refrain from bleeding too much on the page for any given reader’s aggrandizement. I would hope that the quality of what we present and the community we invite you to would be enough for you to want to keep this space healthy and viable.

But for those of you (and that seems to be most of you) who wonder here is a partial list what we do:

–tangibly recognizes Lace and her work
–honors our Admin team; and I hope to adjust our collective goal so we can do that even better
–allows us to pay contributors (and again, more over and above our Basic will allow us to recruit more and pay even better)
–allows us to be generous with paying for conferences, symposia, and the like. Most of the places where we are requested cannot pay us market rate. We still want to be there. We should be paying our full weight, particularly for grass roots orgs
–allows us to pay for resources at market rate as well. Most of what we bring you are orgs like us, small and scrappy. We should be paying full freight. Actually, we are bigger and have stuck around longer than a lot of social justice spaces. We should be setting the standard; this should not be pulling teeth. Buying books at full price, not used, is the only way to get funds in the hands of those who actually wrote it. So we should not flinch at paying 25 dollars instead of 5 dollars, which only benefits the reseller.
–allows for proper dedicated space for Lace on Race. It should not still be in my living room. We need to have places where we can be generous and open and available.
–in theory, should allow for retreat/sabbatical time for me, and to a lesser extent for Admin staff. I work a full time job, on top of another 40+ hours here. In over two years, I have never had a dedicated weekend, much less week or two to do long range planning, and to do the deeper research and outlining I need to do.
–make it possible, someday, that I don’t have to work 80-100 hours a week. That means retirement, and feeling comfortable that my work here can indeed, with my pension, keep me modestly solvent and pay for medical. I am 56 years old and have been burning very thin candles at both ends for 2 years now; that’s not counting the work I was doing before LoR.

All of this, and more, for even our stretch, reach-for-the-stars budget of 6000 a month (which would cover all of the above) would be a bargain. Our Basic Budget is a third of that. Quietly, we should not have an issue with funding that amount with 4000 walkers of whatever tenure. Yet we do. This could well be the third month in a row we do not meet Basic numbers.

One of the boundaries I have set for myself and my self care and my liberation, is no more begging you all. If this is not something that 4000 choose to support even at these modest levels, and I have to find yet another job, we will fold. Graciously, and with deep gratitude for the last two years. But yes, it is indeed unreasonable for me to subsidize this space still further.

So yes, we need you, and we need my anxiety levels go down, and we need to make this a space as relentlessly reliable as we are all working toward being ourselves.

I hope this is the last time this year I need to write something this detailed.


8 responses to “A Quiet Word”

  1. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    I did just want to add to my comment I just posted, before I get to far from it, that I don’t really get to distance myself from what I said, and that I do see the seeking to justify not spending in myself at times, or I probably wouldn’t see it outside of myself. But when I see it, I need to be clear with myself what it’s really about.

  2. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    Jenny, I’ve been reflecting also on what you said, and I wanted to challenge one part of it. If I were paying a certain amount and was told I’d need to pay more, I get that I might ask myself if I could pay more, and if I wanted to prioritize the good or service over something else if necessary to do so. But.

    I would never ask another person providing that service to justify the cost. It’s just really not my business to extract that from them. I might go hunting out what a corporation does with their profits in deciding whether or not to purchase from them, but if I have a relationship with a person providing a service, like we do with Lace here, either I trust or I don’t. Either it’s worth it or it’s not, TO ME. But there’s labor I’m not entitled to. My boss doesn’t ask how I spend my salary. I don’t ask my voice instructor how she spent my lesson fees, and Lace is being asked, by many people, over time, to justify what we don’t want cleft others to justify. A point she already made.

    I appreciate very much that people can engage with Lace on Race for free, because I think not everyone who wants and needs the message has money to spend toward it. I have asked myself if I DO have money I can invest in the message and in my own work here. The answer is yes, so I do. If the answer were no, the. I wouldn’t need Lace to justify why I shouldn’t contribute, and that’s a lot what your supposition sounds like. Not seeking justification for the worth, which is either observable or not, but seeking a reason why it’s worth less. Over and over. I can only imagine the burden of that.

  3. Danielle Joy Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Joy Holcombe

    Yes Laura, it made me feel uncomfortable too, knowing that people are demanding this type of information. It IS interesting to contemplate the places and people where we can comfortably send/spend our money and the places where we demand some type of accountability or proof of worth.

    For me personally, financial engagement here hasn’t carried such a clench as it seems to for some. I’m not sure if it’s because I was raised with the concept of tithing (raised evangelical Christian). I’m not saying this is LIKE tithing. More that a life long practice of carrying out a financial commitment may have made it easier to make this commitment.

    It would be more apt to compare financial engagement here to the way one might pay a personal trainer or an educator but I’m actually horrible about setting aside money for those types of things which feel at times frivolous. Engagement here on the other hand feels very necessary.

  4. Marlise Avatar
    Marlise

    Jenny, I’ve not seen you comment here before. Welcome!

    My immediate thought regarding your comment relate to how we as a culture assign value. There are many products or services that culturally are valued over others, an assigned value that is tentatively at best connected to actual received value. The easiest example I can think of are the countless care professionals that receive minimum wage and low benefits in exchange for a service that has been devalued by our culture but requires intense labor, effort, and service. Keeping that in mind, I think it is important to consider how we assign value to the work of BIPOC. Lace states this dynamic outright in her post.

    “Why activists of color, particularly Black activists, still more specifically Black women activists, are scrutinized and held to a higher standard when it comes to justifying our worth, but are considered less than worthy when it comes to what we produce, even if people consume it regularly, is a question that has an answer, and it is an unsavory one.”

  5. Jenny Avatar
    Jenny

    When you buy a product, take a class or hire a coach, you don’t ask where your funds are going no, but there is one simple reason – you believe you are getting value. If the retailer, tutor or coach asked for $10 more than wanted to pay, you WOULD ask why. When you have got what you want, at the price you were prepared to pay, there is no reason to ask. If people here are asking how their money is spent, they must perceive that they are not getting value for their investment.

    Whether you believe they are is not going to change anything, unless you can find a way of convincing your supporters of the worth of whatever you are giving them.

  6. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    Thank you, Deb. I’ve been trying to articulate why I felt so squiggy to learn this is the information people are wanting from Lace, but I’ve been struggling with a lack of focus in my thinking lately, and couldn’t … quite… get there. But this is it.

    I am pleased to be a sustainer, because I owe remuneration for the great good I gain here. It really can be as simple as that.

    I think capitalism has trained folks like me that driving hard, smart bargains and following the money is a real virtue. But it can make us demanding and invasive and petty and miserly, too, when we become really habituated to it.

    There are a LOT of people we trust just fine with our money, without asking any questions. WHO we feel entitled to question and who we feel we need to question needs to be really REALLY examined. I know because I’ve caught myself out in it.

  7. Kathy Kratchmer Avatar
    Kathy Kratchmer

    I love how you laid this out. ❤️

  8. Deb Chymiak-Isanhart Avatar
    Deb Chymiak-Isanhart

    When you buy a person’s product, you don’t ask where the money is going. Well, unless its a huge corporation and you want to see what charities or politicians it makes donations to.

    When you take a class or attend a seminar you don’t question how tuition will be used.

    When you hire a life coach, you don’t ask how they are using your fee.

    This space is a classroom and anti-racism coaching service rolled into one. Either you find value here or you don’t. If you do, you pay for what you are receiving. If you don’t, you can move on.

    But to ask where the money goes??? Umm…. No.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *