The Shortest Day

The Winter Solstice has a pause at its very heart: the discernible moment between declining sun and rising sun, like the turning point between my inhalation and my exhalation when I am meditating.  It’s a moment of suspension when, simultaneously, nothing is happening, and anticipation is infinite. It was a critical moment in the lives of my European ancestors, and they would set the Yule logs ablaze to hold the night at bay.  They mourned the sun’s loss, and heralded the sun’s renewal; they honored the ephemeral moment of the turn, and the eternal endurance of the cycle.

The Winter Solstice is a time of holding two things at once.

This year, I am approaching the shortest day with a second star prominent in my thoughts, the North Star of Lace on Race: to lessen and mitigate the harm endured by Black and Brown people, and perpetuated by white people, including myself, and white supremacy.  And I have noticed that our walking together here regularly demands that we hold two things at once, too.

Lace on Race approaches the North Star by a strategy of internal growth.  We dig through our minds and our histories to uproot the toxic bindweed of white supremacy.  We strengthen our ability to set aside our domineering, dominating white perspective, and to instead keep ourselves eye to eye with any and all people.  And we establish, within ourselves, higher standards for how we relate to others and how we regulate ourselves, overwriting the white model of tears and excuses, carve-outs and flounces.

Yet while we persistently focus inward to accomplish these things, we absolutely must keep our attention directed to our external praxis, because the work is not about us.  It is about Black and Brown people, and reducing the white harm they endure.  We aren’t working in order to improve ourselves; that is merely the technique, and we can’t ever allow ourselves to forget it.

Lace has also introduced us to the ethics of kind candor and of hesed.  Together, these show us that a strong and healthy love is not merely tender, but also demanding.  This love requires grace and accountability, together.  It urges gentle compassion and frank honesty, atonement and redemption, together.  This love tells us that radical acceptance is ours, forever, and that we must do better, always.

This act of joining a dualism manifests an incredible alchemy.  The medieval Chinese philosopher Zhou Dunyi conceived of this in the taijitu, the black and white circle westerners call yin-yang, which is literally “the diagram of the supreme ultimate”.  The supreme ultimate: the profound power that is generated when we hold two things at once.

The Winter Solstice is December 21st at 10:03 UT.  In this moment when all things are possible, I’ll hold that contemplative pause in my own heart.  And this Solstice, when I gather its power for the year to come, I’ll be thinking of Lace, the Lace on Race community, and our commitment to directing that power at racism, in ourselves and wherever we find it.


7 responses to “The Shortest Day”

  1. Shannon Avatar
    Shannon

    Yes, that laser-focus on dualities is so harmful and so part of white suprematist culture. As is the “if you get this thing then I won’t have it” mindset of competitiveness and scarcity. The scarcity mindset, especially around time, is one of the hardest for me to really grapple with.

  2. Shannon Avatar
    Shannon

    An online community I used to belong to had the motto of “It’s (usually) more complicated than that.” I think that call to hold and be multiple things is partly an acknowledgment of that complexity. And yet also a call for simplicity in terms of recognizing basic truths, like the need to recognize people’s core humanity and that white supremacy is real and foundational to our society. Looking inside ourselves and acknowledging the terrible parts while respecting ourselves and not self-flagellating requires that dualism as well.

  3. Emily Holzknecht Avatar
    Emily Holzknecht

    On the solstice I was outside to witness the conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn on the day of the solstice. Jupiter , the god of thunder and the sky. Saturn, the god of sowing and seed, tasks that belong to the earth. And with their conjunction, earth and sky come together, the duality…usually we call earth and sky coming together the horizon and with the solstice the new year is on the horizon. Burning the yule log, a log saved from the bonfires of last solstice. Holding the past and the present and looking to the future on the horizon.

    I think about the binary in white supremacy culture a lot. The examination of binaries seems to come with the territory when a family member is gender fluid (nonbinary, sometimes one, sometimes the other, sometimes neither, sometimes both, sometimes something else…) and supported. I have yet to think of a binary that hasn’t been used in the oppression of Black and brown people.

    We must continue to examine the binary and make possible not only for holding two things at once, but for possibly holding more than two things at once, for things to be even more complicated than the yin-yang abstraction, for things to be fluid and changing and intricate and sometimes beyond what can easily be forced into a diagram or tidy analogy. Conceiving of the power of duality is important and also let’s not stop there.

  4. Jaime Ballard Avatar
    Jaime Ballard

    I struggle with holding two things, both centering Black people and working on myself so I harm Black less. I appreciate the reminder that I can hold two things. Thinking through this today also reminds me that if I center Black people, that is the primary work I need to do on myself.

  5. Jessie Lee Avatar
    Jessie Lee

    White supremacy does not leave room for dualities. It is greedy and can manage holding only one thing at a time. Good or bad, innocent or guilty, winner or loser, powerful or powerless. White supremacy is all or nothing. There’s no room for “ish” and “ing,” which leaves a lot of room for tears, excuses, carve-outs, and flounces.

    It leaves all the room for white people like me to throw our hands up and say that racial justice isn’t worth the trouble. White people can’t fathom that ceding our power to the people we stole it from in the first place does not mean we’ll be left totally powerless. That’s what white supremacy would delude us into believing, but it’s all a scare tactic to keep us hoarding power so the whole system doesn’t come toppling down.

    I’m seeing more and more the longer I walk here that holding two things at one time is a necessary revolutionary act. Lace on Race is the lab space where I can and must practice that skill *in order to* lessen and mitigate the harm endured by Black and Brown people, perpetuated by white people, including me, and by white supremacy.

  6. Christin Spoolstra Avatar
    Christin Spoolstra

    “We aren’t working in order to improve ourselves; that is merely the technique, and we can’t ever allow ourselves to forget it.”

    The duality is so important. Learning to hold multiple things at the same time will be eternal work for me and it is vital.

    Yes, the internal work changes me and all my relationships for the better. Yes, it is done with sole orientation to our North Star of racial justice.

  7. Rebecca McClinton Avatar
    Rebecca McClinton

    Welcome to authorship here, Christina! Dialectics have fascinated me over the last several years and I have seen them in a whole new way since coming here and seeing how binaries are rooted in white supremacy. I’ve learned the importance in my racial justice work that I be a crock pot instead of a wok (or violently silent), stay in the car with those I disagree with instead of bailing, and balance action with internalization, love with accountability. I still wobble a lot on those teeter totters, but I find I over correct less, and move with a bit more confidence between the binaries. I look forward to that continuing to grow.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *