Breaking Down the Barriers To True Connection

What is  hope?  I’ve always thought of hope as an expectation or anticipation of something (something good) that I know will come to fruition.

But hope is so much bigger or broader than that, and not nearly always wrapped up in a neat and pretty bow.  Hopes can be dashed or stolen.  Hopes are often misguided.  

I had the opportunity recently to have my hopes and expectations around a certain friendship challenged.  I had understood this particular friendship to be especially deep; something akin to family (in a good way).  And I got comfortable in what it seemed we had built; and I formed expectations around both resilience and reliability.  And then we hit some pain points as our paths diverged in some significant ways.  I knew that I had allowed distance to grow and while there was a part of me that did not want to do the relational work necessary to stay in this friendship, I felt it was a part of my praxis to do so.  So I went to her with a plan to have a hard conversation about how to stay in the car together.  To my surprise, she too came with a plan for a hard conversation.  But her plan was different than mine.  Her plan was to pull back from one another and to set some conditions around what we could talk about, and where we could find common ground.  

And it rocked me to my core to realize that this relationship was not the steady, reliable promise I had imagined it to be (even though I too had participated in the aforementioned distancing).  As I’ve taken some time to process this, and specifically the conditions that were set around our conversation, I’ve been reminded of a post Lace wrote a while back about boundaries.  What do we mean by boundaries, but more importantly, how do we often use boundaries, not in service to our health as we may claim, but rather in service to our comfort?  And how do we use boundaries in ways that prevent real relationship from taking place?

It feels strange to be talking about boundaries in a conversation about hope but I guess in this context I’m thinking of the boundaries that we erect as walls and the way that those walls stand in the way of true connection.  

I look at what I have been willing to give of myself in this community.  On the surface, some days I appear to be giving the very best of myself here ~ at least when I look at what I was taught was valuable and important.  I am giving my competence, my work ethic, my time, my resources.  But how often have I held back from giving the very thing Lace asks me to give?  Myself.  My vulnerable and real self.  To be honest about my fears, my power moves, my priorities and my privilege, my questions (still containing the slosh of my bucket though – Lace does not ask me for unbridled self expression).  To be willing to make mistakes in public and to learn IN PUBLIC and to initiate and work through the repair-ING process for as long as it takes.  These are all necessary aspects of genuine connection – but even as I’m writing this, I can see how comfortable I’ve become with my walls.  Oh, I have walls of varying heights. Some are more like a curb at this point, but the foundations of my walls remain, always ready to be built back up.

So back to my hopes….  For 2021 and beyond, my hope for me and my hope for this space are similar.  I hope for true connection (and for myself, that hope contains room for a plan).  I hope for and look forward to watching those connections grow.  My hope is not like a wish ~ unlikely to come to fruition.  My hope has anticipation built in, because like my walls, a foundation for this communal abiding already exists.  Lace has built up a foundation for us using the tools of relational ethics.  She has laid out a road map for the beginnings of this work and is ready to take us deeper. I’m eagerly anticipating the opening of the Lace on Race Café and the growth and connection that will flourish there ~ always in service to the North Star.

My hope is for connection. I hope that for you too! ❤️

Please visit the Discussion Forum for this post
Breaking Down the Barriers to True Connection


31 responses to “Breaking Down the Barriers To True Connection”

  1. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    Which is exactly what you were saying. I agree with you and apologize.

  2. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    I’m very happy to be here. I do hope your hopes come to fruition. Especially if creating a community of folks trying to learn. Thank you for this space.

  3. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    Luckily in my few true friendships, I have yet to experience that. They support my views as much as their own. We learn from each other. I’m sorry this happen to you by a person you trusted and loved.

  4. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    Well put. I live the comparison to a solid marriage. It’s not always the “romance” it’s the day to day being there. As Etta James sang it’s a “Sunday kind of love”. One that last every day and endures past the initial honeymoon stage.

  5. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    Meant to say among rather than between all other groups in the world.

  6. Leanne Nealy Avatar
    Leanne Nealy

    I love that! I come here hoping to see my white fragility and superiority and examine it at a deeper level. I want too break down as many barriers as I can to follow the Praxis. To follow the North Starvand to be a safe place to land. Except that sounds like being a savior which is what I want to steer away from. We are all human beings with these senseless barriers that color brings. In light of history, I guess it’s not surprising. By now, through science, we know we are all the same at a DNA level. In fact I read there are more genetic difference among Africans than among all a groups in the world. Their are more genetic differences among more than throughout.

    We are far more advanced scientifically than we are emotionally.

    This is one of those pesky facts that most white people don’t want to hear. Just like the fact that we all come from one genetic woman “Lucy” in Africa.

  7. Emily Esterly Avatar
    Emily Esterly

    “How often have I held back from giving the very thing Lace asks me to give? Myself. My vulnerable and real self. To be honest about my fears, my power moves, my priorities and my privilege, my questions…To be willing to make mistakes in public and to learn IN PUBLIC and to initiate and work through the repair-ING process for as long as it takes. These are all necessary aspects of genuine connection.”

    This resonates deeply with me- the intense vulnerability of both learning in public and the honesty required for true connection. This is such a unique space – I appreciate the vision for what could be if we were successful in connecting fully, building relationship, growing and learning together. It gives me hope, too, and makes me want to fully participate in the way that’s being asked.

  8. Clare Steward Avatar
    Clare Steward

    Copying error… here is the first paragraph

    What keeps bouncing around in my mind are boundaries. Recently, a previous, prominent community member used the word as a weapon and as an excuse to blow up in a big way and leave, claiming her boundaries had been disrespected and violated.

  9. Clare Steward Avatar
    Clare Steward

    **crossposted in the starters menu**

    disrespected and violated. Others jumped on that declaration, saying they learned so much here and through Lace but, they weren’t able to give what is requested and required to do the work and so, claimed they were setting their own boundaries and leaving.

    Boundaries can be helpful like many tools but dangerous when used to side step the accountability and and work ethic required to build solid praxis for long lasting anti racist work. They are a wall, as Danielle said. They are used to keep others at arms length and secure our comfort and complacency.

    As adults, we are all responsible for managing our can’ts and won’ts in honest ways and we are responsible for pushing ourselves beyond our comfort levels in healthy ways. When crossings get lumpy, that’s when we need to lean in and assess the walls we erect to keep discomfort out and separate being activated from being harmed.

    My hope is to walk with courage and to challenge the walls that spring up as I go, blocking my path and tempting me to abandon the way forward and to revert to behaviors that inflict harm on others while upholding my comfort.

  10. Shannon Avatar
    Shannon

    “To be willing to make mistakes in public and to learn IN PUBLIC and to initiate and work through the repair-ING process for as long as it takes. These are all necessary aspects of genuine connection” I understand that this is part of what is lacking in my racial understanding, real interactions and feedback instead of my internal and intellectual process. I am thankful that this is a place where I can experience this.

  11. Julie Helwege Avatar
    Julie Helwege

    “How do we often use boundaries, not in service to our health as we may claim, but rather in service to our comfort?”

    I didn’t know much about boundaries until joining Lace on Race, and that says a lot about my privilege and supremacy as a white woman.

    Boundaries can be healthy and unhealthy. I can set boundaries that create safety and help me emotionally regulate. I can also set “boundaries” that weaponize, perpetuate discrimination and oppression and build higher, towering walls. I can use my fragility and discomfort to manipulate and describing this as “boundary-setting” is right out of the white supremacy playbook.

    I’ve realized these past six months that I don’t want to be comfortable or unaffected in racial justice work anymore and catering to my own comfort is no longer an option. I want to be relentlessly reliable. A place where BIPOC can rest their sore and exhausted feet. I want to be known as some one who can be counted on. I also want to count on. I want to be described as a white woman who sees eye to eye and loves durably. My online and offline are congruent. I’m trusted and show up with resiliency and resolve. I’m immovable in my Praxis and commitment to our North Star and have the blisters and sores to prove it.

    Reading Dani’s words made me think about deep relationships and the first thing that came to mind is my marriage. Marriage was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made; it’s also been one of the hardest. On my wedding day, I vowed to “love you (Bob) in good times and bad, when life seems easy and when it seems hard, when our love is simple and when it is an effort. I promise to cherish you and always hold you in the highest regard.” I had no idea at the time what any of that really meant, I do now and Hesed love is what deep relationships are all about. And yes, my marriage has been easy and extremely hard. As is this work. It’s expected, and I embrace it.

    If durable love isn’t present in my racial justice work and within this community, I will not be relentlessly reliable and my trustworthiness is not sustainable, same with my marriage. I have to vow and avow similarly.

    It’s why this space is so unique and why being less harmful and much safer can no longer be just my hope, it’s now my reality too. No carveouts, no excuses.

    So I vow in 2021 to lessen and mitigate the harm to BIPOC perpetuated by me. In good times and in bad, when it is easy and when it is hard and when love and walking eye to eye is simple and when it is an effort. I will cherish this community and always hold everyone in the highest regard.

  12. Emily Holzknecht Avatar
    Emily Holzknecht

    A brave approach to relationships…. and a necessary one in the dedication to the work of the relationship, right? Like, without it the Dani and her friend could have gone on for years thinking they were good friends but not really seeing each other for who they are and the relationship for what it is, seeing it as something that it is not. The challenges are necessary in the search for what is real, in the search for real relationships that we can trust, rely on and rest in.

  13. Emily Holzknecht Avatar
    Emily Holzknecht

    I had not thought of that distinction between hope and optimism. I am thinking about Laura’s post about not being a Rip Van Winkle. I wonder if white progressives feel optimism under someone like Obama or Biden and that is why they become inactive and then under someone like Trump they feel hope and that is why they become active. (If there was no hope, there would also be no action.) I am taking away the moral of beware of inactivity due to optimism.

  14. Emily Holzknecht Avatar
    Emily Holzknecht

    *crossposted from facebook*
    A couple months ago (I think…pandemic time is weird) I was expressing how hopeless I felt – about the election (which I was pretty sure would go to Trump), about climate change. I felt angry with so many people which was probably at least in part a reframing of my anger with myself, lashing out to not feel shame. I was making changes at that time though, changes to my behavior and inviting other people to walk with me. My partner said that I was saying I was hopeless, but if I was really hopeless, I wouldn’t be taking action, and I probably wouldn’t feel anger either because the anger is related to hope too. I hoped I would do differently and I didn’t. I hoped others would do differently and they didn’t. So I still saw potential in myself and in others. I still had hope.
    My hope for 2021 is also about connection and resilience. I hope that as I continue to engage people directly with kind candor that I grow my feeling of confidence and resolve in doing that. Right now when I engage people directly and with kind candor, then I spend days afterwards worrying that they will think mistake my directness for anger, that they will think I am rude or mean, that I will lose my connection to them. I don’t know if those feelings will ever go away, but my hope is that they will lessen as I grow my confidence and resolve.

  15. Jessie Lee Avatar
    Jessie Lee

    “going above and beyond even because I am doing more than the other white folks around me” – yes. I’ve also thought this. It seems like another way I try to claim the “good white person” defense while actively harming.
    I have thought more about this line between self-indulgence and authenticity, thanks for asking. I agree with what you said (paraphrasing Lace) about confession without course correction and keeping the question of “How will this land?” front of mind. I’ve noticed that another form of self-indulgence can be making a confession that does pivot to how I will walk differently and mitigate/repair the harm but that pivot is inauthentic and superficial. Like… it’s as deep as I’m willing to go at the time, not as deep as I can go or need to go to divest from white supremacy. It’s still on my terms. I think another question (courtesy of Lace) that can serve as a sort of litmus test/BS detector when reading over a comment is asking myself whether I’m growing or relapsing. I’m growing if I am, like you said, open to the opportunity to learn and course correct and become safer. That requires risk, and risk requires a laying down of entitlement, which I’ve definitely experienced as a marker of growth.

  16. Shay Roberts Avatar
    Shay Roberts

    I love how you call out yourself for your own self-deception. Same here. It’s amazing how easy it can be to lie to myself and convince myself that by doing the bare minimum and just showing up I am doing enough, going above and beyond even because I am doing more than the other white folks around me. But as you say here, this is an unoriginal lie full of entitlement. Your comment here has served as a reminder that there is always more to do and more to root out.
    Your question of self-indulgence or authenticity makes me think of something Lace has said before – and I’m paraphrasing hard here – you can’t just leave your confession out there without addressing how you will do it differently and mitigate/repair the harm. Confession without course correction is self-indulgent. It is a fine line to walk and it’s important to continually ask myself, “How will this land?” I’m still going to get it wrong sometimes, but I do tell myself that when I do, it’s another opportunity to learn and course correct and become safer. Have you given this more though since your first comment?

  17. Jennifer Epstein Avatar
    Jennifer Epstein

    “The opportunity to have my hopes and expectations around a certain friendship challenged.” This is a brave approach to relationships. I’m learning to confront discomfort in my relationships, and to see it as opportunity. The risk is hard, though. And yet, diminished relationships give false comfort.

  18. Danielle Joy Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Joy Holcombe

    Thanks for giving me that extra info. Every situation is going to be different so there will always be times we weren’t sure what to say but what I really was trying to get at was the intentionality of making that change once you recognize the habit (moving from discomfort to walls up). It sounds like you worked to stay in that conversation but have you been formulating your words in case you get another opportunity? Or can you make another opportunity for that conversation? And you don’t need to answer me on those but I imagine it could be helpful to be working through the things you would have said so you are ready if there is another time. And you can already imagine it might get uncomfortable so it will be a good opportunity to practice staying in a conversation and staying focused on the North Star while you do it.

  19. Rhonda Eldridge Avatar
    Rhonda Eldridge

    First of all, thanks. All the italics were supportive to me. Second, let me see if I get it. The specific situation on my mind is that a white male manager at my company today wants to give a white male employee (who happens to report to me) a large end of year bonus. I have been beating myself up tonight because I thought it was a perfect opportunity to point out how systemic racism plays out when we aren’t looking at our entire staff and looking for ways to lessen and mitigate the harm (and promote for that matter) the work done by the black and brown people on our staff. In the moment, I couldn’t think of the right words to say that he would ‘hear’ and I knew I was really uncomfortable. I did, however, calmly say that the amount seemed a bit Hight and I hoped we were considering others. Is that kind of what you are saying or am I way, way off?

  20. Danielle Joy Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Joy Holcombe

    Wow – I only intended to italicize the word process. Oops

  21. Danielle Joy Holcombe Avatar
    Danielle Joy Holcombe

    Hi Rhonda ~ When I read “the willingness to grow my capacity to stay in discomfort” it sounds to me like you’re describing a process; one that may happen over time. What if you just STAYED in discomfort at the next opportunity and practiced the tools of emotional regulation? I can’t know exactly how you meant it but it just made me think for a minute about how Lace talks about doing this work “with all deliberate speed” and of course, as we learn, things about our behavior will change over time. But sometimes I think its important to just say that next time I find myself activated in this way, I’m going to do this, and then do it.

    I like what you said about how you enter a conversation open. That’s something I now need to say I will do ~ and then do. I’ve noticed I tend to enter a conversation often either assuming I know what the other person is thinking, or working to figure out what they might want from me. That never gets me off on the right foot and immediately puts walls up for me.

  22. Rhonda Eldridge Avatar
    Rhonda Eldridge

    I have this sense that my walls go up and down so easily. I enter a conversation open, vulnerable, ready to speak my mind and with the intention to mitigate the harm that I do to black and brown people then, there is a certain level of discomfort, almost like a water level that gets too high, and I back down. And the walls go back up again. Is hope the willingness to grow my capacity to stay in the discomfort?

  23. Shannon Avatar
    Shannon

    I try to distinguish between hope and optimism. For me, optimism is believing that things will get better; hope is believing things can get better. Optimism is rooted in being passive – even if you do nothing, things will just get better on their own. Hope is rooted in action – things will get better if we take action. I’m a pretty vulnerable person. People say I read like a book no matter what, so I just embrace it. Where I tend to fall down on connection is the maintenance side of things. I get so caught up in my “to do” list that I don’t reach out to people as much as I would like to. I’ll respond if other people reach out to me, but I never take the initiative. So I will continue to work to take that initiative, both in deepening my existing personal relationships and here.

  24. Christina Sonas Avatar
    Christina Sonas

    “…to realize that this relationship was not the steady, reliable promise I had imagined it to be…” This is where I find myself in this piece: the not steady, not reliable promise I imagine myself to be. I want to keep my own hopes and expectations very narrow: to meet, even surpass, the hopes and expectations that BIPOC have of me. Their weary and 100% justified suspicion is that I will perpetuate white supremacy; their hope and expectation is that I will pull my $}!& together to lessen and mitigate harm to them, from myself and from other white people. That means working without my safety net of white supremacy: it means taking significant risk, especially with “my vulnerable and real self”.

  25. Rebecca McClinton Avatar
    Rebecca McClinton

    Thank you for your words, Danielle. I can only be my best self when authentic about my whole lot, and that includes how to stay in the car with people, how to lean in instead of distance from difficult things, and knowing when and where my walls are, and what they’re keeping in and out. Pivoting to race, I know I’m less guarded and anxious speaking out about racial justice topics but I have room to grow for sure. Your words are a kind and firm reminder for how guardedness can cause harm. I was just doing some therapy work on this topic yesterday, and will continue rooting to that end so I can show up with my best and most authentic self, full force.

  26. Jessie Avatar
    Jessie

    Thank you for this, Danielle.
    When I’m not coming to engage mindfully, I can be really skilled at self-deception. If my BS detector isn’t functioning at full capacity, I can deceive myself into believing that I’m offering the best of me when the truth is that I’m holding back. As you describe, there’s a difference between holding back by resisting the impulse to engage in unbridled self-expression and holding back by withholding parts of myself… and concealing my power moves, fears, priorities, privileges, questions, etc. And I’m not original in that way. I’m just like any other white person who feels entitled to being judged favorably for doing the bare minimum.

    Speaking of questions, I think one area where I’m uncertain is how to walk the line between sharing my shortcomings authentically so that I and others can learn from them, and confessing my sins self-indulgently in order to relieve myself of their burden on my conscience. It’s hard to tell sometimes, but maybe that’s another story I tell myself to let myself off the hook for getting it wrong. I am going to think on this more.

  27. Shay Roberts Avatar
    Shay Roberts

    Yes, I have seen this in myself as well – something that I think or name as a defense mechanism (something uncontrollable and innate), is actually a weapon purposefully wielded in service of protecting myself, my comfort and my safety and my well-being. For example, when I want to shut down, blow up, or walk away it’s easy to name these as an automatic and uncontrollable defense mechanism – part of the freeze, fight, or flight response. However, I can learn to recognize these responses and choose differently – but only if I’m doing the intentional, internal work of confronting choice points ahead of time, before they become pain points and I resort to the violent tactics I’ve learned.

  28. Shay Roberts Avatar
    Shay Roberts

    Crossposted:
    Powerful words here, Dani! Boundaries in service to comfort – this is a safety net that I cling to in the name of my own comfort and safety. I can’t truly have skin in the game unless I’m willing to abandon these walls, de-center myself, and authentically engage and stand with Black and brown leaders, friends, and even strangers. Even while I’m doing the necessary, internal work, I can still choose to engage with as much vulnerability as I wish. To hold back from vulnerably exposing my true thoughts and fears and privileges, my vulnerable, real self as Dani names. Even as in tearing the walls down, I cling to the foundations because I know I can quickly build those walls right back up when I come to a pain or choice point. My hope is to do this no more. To fully abandon my foundations for the ones modeled and laid here in our space by Lace and other walkers – vulnerability, connection, seeing eye-to-eye, seeing and being seen. All with the goal of becoming safer and lessening and mitigating the harm endured by Black and brown people, perpetuated by white people like me.

  29. Nichola Avatar
    Nichola

    Definitely something I am working on. That whole “least said…” mentality as well as defensiveness. I am trying to push myself out of my comfort zone and hope that it will help eventually.

  30. Vicki Avatar
    Vicki

    There is a paradox here that I am working to resolve. It requires additional perspective on my part that I feel like I haven’t internalized yet. Boundaries (i.e. separateness) used in service to community (i.e. togetherness). Comfort should never be my goal, it should be a byproduct of living authentically in community with others. In the last 5-7 years, many of my relationships feel like they have had boundaries for comfort put up. We have done just like Danielle and her friend-mutual distancing. Now I see how harmful that is for me as an individual, and for the whole of the community. I hesitate to do the real work that needs to be done-to be my authentic self while allowing others to do the same, while working together to build a community that meets everyone’s needs. I am starting to see the need to focus on the margins, though. To work to bridge the areas of greatest divide first. To focus on the women of color as community leaders and shapers; ways of holding them up, supporting them, and amplifying their voices. I still would not understand this without LoR. Hope and faith go hand in hand for me. If I hope for a better future, then I must have faith that it can be made manifest. I must act in faith to bring it to reality. And love must be my underlying motivation for all of it.

  31. Christin Spoolstra Avatar
    Christin Spoolstra

    As I started reading this post I paused to respond to a friend congratulating the US on Biden’s victory. And my response was devoid of hope. Instead of feeling the hope of joy and anticipating, I quashed the congratulations in the need to remain cautious until the electoral college meets, until the lawsuits are resolved, until Congress certifies the results, until Biden is sworn in, until, until…. And I know I do this as a defense mechanism (and I’m starting to see more and more from LoR how what I deem a defense mechanism is/can also be a weapon). If I do not hope, I despair myself out of action. If I do not hope, I am divesting myself from fighting for my hope.

    I love what Dani said here: “My hope is not like a wish ~ unlikely to come to fruition. My hope has anticipation built in…” Hope is action.

    So my hope moving forward is that I hope more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *