The Four Tenets: Plant Roots

This is a story about sticking around.

This is a story about Hesed.

This is a story about muddy knees and chipped fingernails; a story of relentlessness, and reliability, and resilience.

This is a story of soil.

Terrible soil. Not fertile and loamy, but sandy and poor. Soil not worthy of the name. Soil that was more accurately called dirt.

Soil that blew off and made my porch dusty; with gopher holes and weeds and trash that came in after garbage day.

Soil that was not at all amenable to orange trees, or anything else for that matter. Or, so I first thought.

I have a front field. Half an acre of dirt, that has lain fallow since I bought the property 20 years ago. It is often brown and barren, except when it rained and the grass, mixed with mostly weeds, grew.

And grew, and grew. These years I have been alone, sometimes they grew above my head; good for nothing, or, so I thought. So dense and uninviting that even Tikka rejected it. I would try to take care of it myself in fits and starts, but the job was just too damn much for one woman with two full time jobs.

One day, I was at the wooden fence line, staring at what felt like my failure. The worst property on the block. Every time I came up the driveway, I studiously ignored the tangle. Sometimes I would go out to at least pick up the trash from the field, always in shadow, at night, so the neighbors wouldn’t see. That front field was my shame. A metaphor: that nothing good would ever grow; and that what did spring up had no value. Like me.

As I sank deeper, I heard a voice: Teacher.

“Gather the tools,” Teacher said. Teacher, who spent years, decades, making sure her charges had all the things they needed in their desks; scissors; glue; sharp pencils; lined paper; flash cards. And, when they forgot them, a crisp but kind reminder to cheek their backpacks.

Gather the tools. Teacher had no idea what she was asking me to do. The tools were in the workshop, a place I had hardly entered since my husband was gone. To go to the tools, to dust off, and sharpen, and oil and use, meant going into recesses and dark places in that workshop. Meant that I would remember. And meant that I would prepare myself for pain; the pain of that remembering; of trauma, of loss, of despair. To use the tools meant finally acknowledging that it was indeed just me. That no one was going to come and use them to break soil but me. That I had to not just gaze at the field in helpless impotence, but that I had to take responsibility for its health, and for my own.

Getting past the cobwebs and trying to figure out how to use the unfamiliar, because Robert had handled all of it before, was a challenge indeed. I used the wrong tools the wrong way; I got blistered and chapped. Some were dry and cracked and broke at the first effort. I was so discouraged.

“Invest in new,” Teacher advised. New? Was Teacher kidding? I had been living in clench mode ever since Robert left and Teacher was telling me to invest? In things I didn’t even know how to ask for at the garden center; stumbling and fumbling my way through what I needed, and my cart filling up and a shaking hand as I handed over hard earned cash I wasn’t at all sure would be replaced.

Now what? What am I supposed to do with this……this stuff?

“Read the directions. Then follow them.” Such easy advice. But how often do we, do I, actually read the directions before we attempt? For me, not often. Of course I know how to use a cutter, and a blower, and that thing that digs up tumbleweeds. Except that I didn’t. And stopping and reading and checking–and heeding– made the difference.

I remember at church when faced with the big coffee urn. There is a big sign, probably placed by Teacher, that says “Read the directions FIRST.” Welp. I had made coffee before; I didn’t need a tutorial on how to use this one. Which is how I wound up cleaning up brown water and coffee grounds. Then I went into the drawer. And read the directions.

Now with knowledge, I felt more secure. But going at a half acre alone for the few minutes or hours I could spare were not nearly enough. It rained a lot this year; more than usual in San Diego. I would make a small dent, and the weeds would spring right back up. It was Sisyphus pushing the rock up the hill, again and again and again. I was bruised and sore and tired.

“Ask for help,” Teacher said. “Raise your hand and just ask.”

Ask. Something very hard for me to do. Impossible, really.

If I asked, that meant letting someone up the driveway so they could see the depth of my shame, my not-knowing, my failed efforts. If I asked, someone could ridicule me. Someone would say the job of fixing the tangled failure was just altogether too big. You need to have wobbly knees and the sorest of backs to do the seemingly impossible.

“Ask and watch and learn. Ask and watch and learn.”

And so I did. and Mr. B came with his son and his truck, and made short work of the front field. He held my face in his calloused hands and looked at me with nothing but love and empathy, knowing without my telling him of my struggles. “We will make it beautiful,” he said.

“Together.”

Teacher, with her tea, by the (only seemingly) barren orange tree, smiled.

And so it was. Beautiful. At least not an eyesore. And the orange tree bloomed, and bore the first fruits it had in years.

Later, I told a version of this story to a new friend. A friend who knew of fields. She runs an organic farm, which was news to me, and she had the instructions in her head to make fields fertile again. To make it not only presentable, but producing. Another teacher.

“Mustard greens. We will plant mustard greens!”

Mustard greens have many uses for fallow fields: they hold the topsoil in; they are edible (lucky for me I love greens), and they make beautiful yellow flowers which will please the eye. More importantly, though, they nourish the soil. R. told me to plant and grow, and plow under, plant, grow, plow, for at least two year’s cycles. The soil will be ready to nurture new growth.

But would they grow? I asked.

R looked at me, with kind eyes. Anywhere weeds grow, good growth can happen. That sank deeply into my soul, like so many orange seeds.

It will take awhile, but our newly enriched soil will be able to nurture so many more trees, and other life. This is not a one and done. But the harvest is coming.

Dig deep.


18 responses to “The Four Tenets: Plant Roots”

  1. Julia Tayler Avatar
    Julia Tayler

    This was really beautiful. I hadn’t seen it before but I really saw a lot of the way I stumble through things in here. I seldom read the directions. How hard could it be? Also, with google I use it as a shortcut. I need to be patient and follow instructions. I have a hard time asking for help too. I realize that I have people who would help but I do have to ask. It has always been hard – I tend to think I can and should do it all. I see a great parallel in doing this work. Like expecting to buy a few books and be done. It takes asking for help and listening and practicing. The soil will get better but we have to give it time. I like gardening too but admit that I just grab tools and make them work. Patience is important and underrated.

  2. Rebecca Behar Avatar
    Rebecca Behar

    “Anywhere weeds can grow, good growth can happen” ~ Ms. Lace Watkins.
    A parable of a garden, a metaphor I joyfully lose myself in, and find myself in, simultaneously.
    If I could spend any day exactly as I chose, it would be working in, walking in, sitting in a garden. I love soil. I mean like, in a nerdy way. The smell, the feel (texture, granularity, porosity and tilth), the critters living within it, all the element of it – rock bits to organic matter. I cannot attribute this quote to an author, but I read it somewhere, and it stayed with me: “Despite all our accomplishments, we owe our existence to a six-inch layer of topsoil and the fact it rains.”
    Enough about my favorite passion – pivoting to race, to inner work, to the metaphorical teachings of the garden, the gardener, the teacher, your friend the organic farm owner, Mr. B and his son, the helpers.
    Every symbol in this story resonates with me. When facing my inner racism, I the am hesitant gardener: I feel fear, pain, shame, guilt, anger, insecurity – and I seize up or as you say, Lace, “blow up, shut down, or run away.” I want out of the car! Stop the world, I want to get off! I resist want to looking at my messy, unproductive field. When I finally do look at my inherent racism, I don’t know where to start, how to do repair or re-script the default script. I’m not sure if I have the strength and persistence to transform barren clay/ entrenched racism, into fertile ground/ anti-racism.
    The teacher is the small voice in my head that says, “Try anyway. Start anywhere. Mistakes are learning experiences. Have a go at it. When you fall down, get up and see what you tripped over.”

    Teachers are everywhere and school is always in session if I chose to be open to learning. I’m not always open to it, when it comes to racism. I’m in new territory in some ways, on a familiar path in others. But if I really want to see the potential in this barren ground, I’m going to have to let go of everything I learned about gardening, that I thought was true, so I can make room for new ideas, better suited to make this plot of land useful. The old way I treated this earth was not productive. It wasn’t sustainable. It was hurting the land. It was self centered. I planted whatever I wanted, it was all about me, self-centered. I wasn’t listening, observing, paying attention. I wasn’t in partnership with the land, I was stomping all over it – like a land owner- not a land lover, a steward, a nurturer. I was all take take take. Me. Me. Me. I. I. I. Frankly, I completely bored with hearing my own voice. I want to be quiet, so I can hear the sounds of the garden.

    The teacher is you, Lace, and others. The teacher is this community. The teacher is other walkers trying to make their reclaim their gardens and fashion them into something else, something new, something better. The teacher is BIPOC people’s lived experiences and right not only to exist but thrive. A garden of only one crop is useful for a few years…but no living thing can survive on mustard greens alone. We need all the plants to make a functional ecosystem. We need diversity. We need inter-relationships in feedback loops that balance and enhance each other. Mono-cropping is only going to work for a little while, it can’t last. True in agriculture. True in wild nature. True in the family of humanity.

    Maybe…. some day… I will become a teacher, an organic farmer, a helper…but I will never stop being the student gardener, the curious gardener, the quietly listening and patiently watching gardener…paying attention to the wisdom and rhythms and lessons – the truth of the gardens. the one within me, and the one surrounding me that I share with others.

  3. Shara Cody Avatar
    Shara Cody

    I gather the tools and read the directions- Lace gives us the guidelines as starters and is constantly providing us content to help direct us on our journey towards our North Star.
    I’m still at the stage of pulling the weeds and replacing them with newly planted roots. I think this will always need to be done as I root out white supremacy in me. I see that those newly planted roots need to be tended and cared for constantly because only weeds grow when you walk away from the directions. The soil is the foundation from which the harvest will spring and the harvest is not for me but for Black and brown people in order to lessen the harm they endure by white supremacy and white people including me.

  4. Kerri Fowlie Avatar
    Kerri Fowlie

    Returning. Trying to pick myself up and walk. I guess I thought the soil I was starting with wasn’t so bad. Being “a good person” has been such a big part of my own identity that when my shovel hit rocks and stubborn roots, I found it just too threatening to what I believed was good soil, my soil. So I downed tools and disappeared into my own quicksand of shame. I believed that at my foundation, I was a good person. I watched others trip themselves up and leave this space. I pitied these white “others” knowing that they maybe just weren’t quite as virtuous as me. Having spent some time in therapy on several occasions over the course of my life, I can “work” cognitive behavioural therapy: I can point to the evidence that “proves” I’m a good person. So what do you do when you hear yourself throw up every defence that you thought you were “better than”? I felt shame, embarrassment and anger. I went straight to offence in my thoughts: those same, predicted, weak, worn cries – striking from the victim position. I was overwhelmed by my own shame and my foundational belief that I was a “good” person lay like so much rubble at my feet. So… I’ll pick out the rubble of my soil, which looks just like everyone else’s. I’ll load it into our communal wheelbarrow, to be discarded and I’ll keep turning over the soil, more humble and … connected.

  5. Miela J Gruber Avatar
    Miela J Gruber

    It was beautiful reading this again at the end of 2020. I notice I am both a little ragged around the edges, and more resilient and reliable at the center. I also noticed reading this that I still have some edges of shame about my weeds, but also the experience from being here that I will most likely be able to see, and plow through those weeds with the candor of you all, and don’t need to be afraid of that, but welcome it. I see a lot of growing edges in groups I am in now, I recognize how new community as a reflex white people are. And how hard it is to move them from the space of talking about things, to doing them. Reading this and feeling those whispers of shame still there, that I wasn’t aware of until reading this, I can see where my edge is this year-to shift to thinking of that the way this amazing essay prescribes. I had a spiritual teacher once say all truama, all shame is “grist for the mill” toward spiritual growth, and its been a supportive mantra for PTSD work for myself and others, not dismissive, but as a way to say-there is value here, not just pain and brokeness. This essay was a very gentle wake up call that those little whispers of fear and shame around this work can be met and softened with this awareness that these are weeds, that point in the direction of future growth and better muscles when allowed to be seen by my community. This feels both sobering and uplifting and girding up, uncomfortable but hopeful, and quiet and heart-softening- sensations I have come to associate with deeper truth.

  6. Kerri Fowlie Avatar
    Kerri Fowlie

    Growing up in Iowa, I love a good story about soil and its metaphorical meanings. This was one of the best! Thank you, Lace.

    I know shame and failure. I know overwhelm. I don’t know that specific loss of life partner, and I’m afraid of it. My husband has his domain and I have mine. I don’t go into his sheds because I have no desire to know how to use/care for his tools. I appreciate the dread of taking on that burden of responsibility. Unlike you, I can ask for help, but my problem is inertia. Overwhelm causes me to shut down. My depression rolls across me and I submit. I’m interested in your turning point and the impetus for that.

    It took lockdown and my “consumption” of George Floyd’s murder, to shift my gears and start me rolling down this bumpy path. I had the honour of having a number incarcerated Black men spend time in my classroom up to that point. I had taught two Black men, in particular, who had missed out on their education because of poverty and a genocide in their native countries. They showed me their vulnerability and aspirations in our one-to-one conversations. I readily identified as a mothering figure for them as I asked about their school years and reassured them that they were bright and good and worthy. I pondered their futures and wanted to battle for them in the place of their mothers, but I recognised my folly and so contented myself with watching them learn and gain confidence.

    There have been many unique, flawed, beautiful human beings who have allowed me to see them without their “hardman” masks. I am so honoured by that. So they have prepared my “ground” over the years. Our mutual humanity nurtured us both. Knowing that many of these men have done terrible, violent things to other people, but that they are still valuable human beings in their own rights, capable of love, loyalty and compassion enables me to understand that my own white-stained racism can be tamed and rooted out with the oversight and encouragement I find here, if I will let down my mask, be vulnerable and try. It gives me comfort and hope that there can be change and “good” growth, even when a barren, dust-blown field appears overrun with sickly weeds and trash.

  7. Konstanze Avatar
    Konstanze

    And then : grow. I shouldn’t stop right before the magic becomes tangible. Grow and harvest.

  8. Konstanze Avatar
    Konstanze

    This was beautiful.
    Finding the internal motivation, facing the fears and the past, getting prepared, looking for guidance, asking for help, accepting help. Each step so very difficult.

  9. clare steward Avatar
    clare steward

    This was so beautifully written and inspiring. . I think it is human nature to protect self from hurt and trauma and sometimes not facing it is needed in order to simply survive. When the time comes to address pain/trauma, it can feel so overwhelming and embarrassing and it is difficult to ask for help because that requires becoming really raw in front of others, exposing all the hurts and failures.

    When it comes to anti-racism work, the things buried deeply in my tool shed are the past failures I have had in recognizing innate biases, recognizing my failure to fully support my BIPOC friends and family, my failure to fully understand the extent,depth and gravity of racism as it permeates EVERYTHING. To be able to name my intentional and willful ignorance instead of placing the blame on factors outside of me is an essential first step in clearing my field. Reading the instructions…..oh my gosh, I am reading and listening and learning and expanding my knowledge and as I engage in the required readings and posts in this space, my list of topics to study and explore have exploded. I appreciate all of the teachers in this space that have prodded, prompted, corrected and guided me and other walkers. Seeing our efforts as a group bear fruit in the chromebook initiative is encouraging and I am excited to continue to lay down roots and see what blossoms next.

  10. J Crane Avatar
    J Crane

    I can see this as a metaphor for so many things. As a metaphor for myself doing antiracism work, I feel deeply how hard it is to look at the waste white supremacy and colonialism has made of this land. I feel despair and hopelessness at the thought of trying to make it better. But I just need the new tools (the old ones are so tainted by past trauma), new knowledge, and a lot of work, day in and day out, adapting as the land changes, asking for help from and listening to following the direction of the Divine and of Black, disabled, and indigenous Women of Color. And it will all be worth it. The world will become more beautiful and fruitful than we can even begin to imagine.

    There is so much more imagery just in the orange tree that I’m not sure I can access without a dose of white saviorism. Contrasting it to trees that bear strange fruit. Seeing that it’s barrenness is related to lack of resources and the infertility of the soil surrounding it, not a failure on it’s own part. It’s roots are good and it’s fruit just waiting for us to put in the hard work of improving the soil.

  11. Leslie Avatar
    Leslie

    Beautiful imagery and storytelling. “Anywhere weeds grow, good growth can happen,” calls to my mind the idea of the wounded healer and hopefulness that pain can be roots for positive change. Listening to the pain of others and being mindful of harm reduction/how to actually be helpful to them is vital to community building.

    There is also a beautiful reminder in there for me that when I see someone not taking care of a glaring problem in their life, I’m usually not looking at all the obstacles there may be preventing this person from taking what seems to be a simple step towards a solution (but actually is a huge, complicated task.)

  12. Amanda Avatar
    Amanda

    There are some deep parallels here. Not only because I’m beginning to work through my own trauma (not related to current events), but because I have realized the trauma caused by the loss of BIPOC lives has affected individuals that I care about.

    In order for me to be a helpful voice in this time I first have to listen. I have to follow their lead and I have to do so in order to bring about healthy growth.

  13. Karen Avatar
    Karen

    I love this! Wow, I had been seeing the orange tree allusions and was curious, and my curiosity is sated while my enthusiasm is revved up. “Anywhere weeds grow, good growth can happen.”
    There will be pain and loss. Neglect and attention. We can listen to teacher. Buy tools. Ask for help. Work hard. Be patient. Be relentless, reliable and resilient. Be in relationship with people, animals, and the elements of the earth. Shame. Discouragement, encouragement. Persistence. Love and empathy. I LOVE THIS! Thanks for sharing this story. It has inspired me. It has motivated me. It has touched me. It has helped me.

  14. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    Faith isn’t something I’m good at. Thomas is my favorite apostle. When I started here, when I said I was all in, I wasn’t… skeptical… exactly. But I’m not sure I really believed, because I had, in all my work to that point, created room for knowing better, but not really for believing it could do much better.

    I don’t know where I’m at right now. Probably somewhere early in first mustard green season. But this community, Lace, and your awe-inspiring vulnerability with us, has made room for faith that I can make it through a couple years and see real bounty. That’s something I didn’t know I needed and lacked, until just now, sitting on the bus reading your words, when I just now felt it. Faith. Thank you.

  15. Deb Chymiak-Isanhart Avatar
    Deb Chymiak-Isanhart

    I love this imagery. I love your writing. And I thank you for the vulnerability you have shared in this piece. The reminder that this work is never “one and done.” The inspiration to keep working on ground (people) that seems unlikely to yield anything; to maybe try a different tool or approach. The need to ask for help when needed — and to offer help to others. The need to continue to tend my own ground and roots.

  16. Karina Avatar
    Karina

    You speak of overcoming deep shame, overwhelm, resignation, sadness, and fear to purchase the tools, read the instructions, ask for help, and take the actions reliably and patiently, over time, to grow roots and bear fruit. I hear you. All of these steps are required.

  17. Zoe Brookes Avatar
    Zoe Brookes

    Thank you for your inspiration. The road is rocky indeed. Taking small steps at planting roots.

  18. Varda L Avatar
    Varda L

    I’m still here. Still messing up. Still learning. Figuring out where the instructions are and how to read them. Weedy. But not barren. So thank you for that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *