Sometimes, To Move Toward Love…Means To Move Toward Death

I am shaken. By beauty; by truth.

I have just read this piece by Carvell Wallace in the New York Times Magazine about the film out now, ‘Queen & Slim’. 

I have pulled out only a few bits, but I am going to see it tonight, based on this meditation alone.

I say meditation because that is exactly what it is; a meditation on love; on life; on death; on being fully alive even as you are hurtling toward death. 

From Wallace:

Lately I have come to the conclusion, and you may disagree, that pretty much every experience we have moves us either toward life or away from it. There are some things that suck the life out of you, that make you feel smaller and less human, that alienate you from yourself; they calcify your fear and carve a monument out of your emptiness. Then there are those that bring you closer to life, that grow in you the desire to create, to nurture, to see beautiful things and become them. This is the love that increases your attachment to people and animals, makes you smile at children or go outside to see the moon. Every experience is either life-affirming or life-denying.

Those who know me well know I don’t watch violent movies, and this movie promises violence. Yet, as I read Wallace’s meditation I was reminded that I swim in violence; my refusal to look at kool aid blood on a screen when I am drenched in the real thing in my psyche and my soul is, in this case, a dodge. I am already sprayed with bullets; my irises are red, so one of the few holdovers of my self imposed rigidity is no longer needed; no longer valid.  Wallace said this, “There is just one trick. It sometimes happens that to move toward love — true, active, life-affirming love — means to move toward death”.

There is just one trick. It sometimes happens that to move toward love — true, active, life-affirming love — means to move toward death.

We are talking about this, this, this—this considered disintegration in the current On Being Series post with angel Kyodo Williams. We are talking about this being an intentional act, to clear the detritus that does not spark justice–another way of saying what does not spark love–so there can be room for what we say we want. 

We must remember though, that we are all, all of us, saying this from a place of deep privilege; to be able to have the choice of what to clear and what to keep, rather than being evicted from your beloved and cherished scaffolding, the artifacts of your life spread around you on hard concrete at a tenement stoop, as it is when one is evicted; one’s schemas and constructs and assumptions and Self carted out by dispassionate or even hostile landlords and supers. 

For so many of us, that is what it is like on the daily; every day facing a three day notice to rent (buy into a society bent on our destruction) or quit (saying no and making the ‘choice’ to become an intellectual and emotional fugutive whose keys to that society no longer work, if they ever did at all)

Left then, to sort out the jumble at the bottom of the stoop; the sacred artifacts of our life from the chaff of existence, all while passerby gawk and sneer and judge, as you walk off with only the treasures you can carry in your own scarred arms, that is the truth of so many of us, left to construct something new while so much is left at the curb, to be picked through and approprated (looted) by those who stood by, the rest hosed away, but still insisting that beauty can still be found and re created despite it all–that is what those who have not the luxury of time and of storage must do.

More Wallace:

What makes this a black movie is not just that it’s about black people or that it was made by black people. It is a black movie because it is first and foremost about loving black people, loving us in every way and however we are — when we are angry, when we are frightened, when we are kind and when we are hurting. It is easy to love us when we are dead, our emotions suspended in history like a bug trapped in amber.

“It is easy to love us when we are dead”. My breath stopped for a moment, and mind went to a woman I know intimately; a woman who has longed for death for decades. She said much the same thing to me as Wallace says here; that she is not angry or even particularly depressed or sad. But that living in a world that hates her for more than half a century, and loving that world anyway but never having that love reciprocated, makes her yearn for a time when the world might finally love her a little. And the only way she can see clear for that to happen is for her to die. Because maybe, just maybe, she too might be one of the lucky ones whose humanity is finally found in her expiration. I lock eyes with her as she says this and internally rock with recognition. Yes. She might be lucky. She might be truly seen in death. I get it. I fight it. I get it. 

Wallace again:

This film loves us when we are alive. And that is a love that our country denies us, seemingly compulsively. When we are making culture or sports or funny memes we are embraced, but when we are hurt or grieving, angry or frightened, we are out of line.

We see this here in Lace on Race. But not just here; we face this in the almost sure betrayals feared in the risk of relationship with those who have standards we are held to, but elide for themselves. We see it in the expectations of supplication and demands for subordination; and the schemas that white people still hold, even when they feel they’ve Kondo-ed themselves, we see the entitlement to pick through our belongings and offer them back to us–sometimes at the steepest of prices–that of relationship; of connection; of abiding, not seeing that in doing so they are then just another landlord; just another super. The distortion of Meeting, only on their terms is not love. 

But what is?

Finally, again from Wallace:

This is what they are living against together, a world that wants everything from black people except our truth.

And so I ask of you all now: What if you could indeed lock eyes and hold yourself as truth was told, without looting, without running?

I will go to this movie. I know I will be changed.


16 responses to “Sometimes, To Move Toward Love…Means To Move Toward Death”

  1. Julia Tayler Avatar
    Julia Tayler

    What if you could indeed lock eyes and hold yourself as truth was told, without looting, without running?
    That is the goal and I’m getting stronger. That is the goal – eyes locked. Like someone mentioned below – I have a hard time with eye contact. My eyesight isn’t great and I’ve always been shy so it has been a challenge. As I have gotten older (and smarter?) I realize that my reluctance to make eye contact isn’t good for relationships and my goals of listening and being a true friend. I need to be able to look everyone in the eye especially myself. Parts of me need to die including my shyness in order to truly show up and be the person I want to be.
    I never read this post originally (it was before I joined – which just shows I have a lot to catch up on) and it really helped solidify the more recent post on love and death. I tried to read the original article but it’s behind the paywall now. I hadn’t heard of the movie but that’s not surprising – I’m not a real movie person but am going to look for it.

  2. Grace Bannerman Avatar
    Grace Bannerman

    What if you could indeed lock eyes and hold yourself as truth was told, without looting, without running?
    I don’t think I’m there yet, or can’t be sure I wouldn’t loot, or I acknowledge in myself the instinct to loot and/or run. From here, I would be glad to get there (though there is no fixed “there.”). If I could hold myself in that way, I imagine I would be able to have more authentic and challenging relationships, and be more accustomed to my own discomfort and living with it sometimes and letting it galvanize me other times.
    A lot of the time, my comfort involves avoiding complexity, and loving living people, none of whom are perfect, means engaging with complexity and change. The fact that even inauthentic love of a fixed idea of a person that can be used in various ways to various ends (e.g. the “Santa Claus-ification” of Dr. MLK Jr.) is desirable illustrates how much any love is lacking, or denied, or withheld. I will seek out more ways to see powerful love, like in Queen & Slim, and live that love in my own life, practicing in many different relationships to improve my skill at it.

  3. Meg Hanebutt Avatar
    Meg Hanebutt

    I come here from your recent post “Commentary for to choose to love is to choose death” that references this post. I am eager to read Carvell Wallace’s piece and to rewatch Queen & Slim, but first I want to sit with and respond to this quote of yours, Lace:

    “Yet, as I read Wallace’s meditation I was reminded that I swim in violence; my refusal to look at kool aid blood on a screen when I am drenched in the real thing in my psyche and my soul is, in this case, a dodge.”

    I know this feeling, and you sum it up so perfectly here. There is a New York Times podcast called The Rabbit Hole that I have dodged listening to after the first two episodes because it was mentally and emotionally too bloody for me. It follows the psychological and online journey of a young white man, from the seemingly harmless place of watching YouTube and playing video games to his ending up in an right-wing white supremacist group. I cringed, cowered, and haven’t listened again, but I realize that this is a dodge. This is the kind of opportunity we white women and white-adjacent women need to take, an opportunity to show courage, by listening to the deep, dark, and scary corners of the white supremacist psyche in order to understand and rewire them. I realize that I have been “drenched in the real thing in my psyche” as a mixed-race, white-adjacent woman, and there is privilege in that. And with that privilege comes responsibility.

  4. Christin Spoolstra Avatar
    Christin Spoolstra

    When I read the post, I thought of looking in a mirror and holding the truth reflected back at me, but I love how you’ve taken it so much more. I need to be better at hearing the truth from BIPOC. I don’t know if I can ever not run and not loot in my own thoughts/reflections (partly because there’s so much context that I as a wyt woman don’t understand/internalize), but I can get closer to hearing and accepting the unvarnished truth from others whose perspective I desperately need.

  5. Christin Spoolstra Avatar
    Christin Spoolstra

    I loved that phrase as well. Sometimes we need to break something apart in order to rebuild it correctly. Sometimes that something is us.

  6. Christin Spoolstra Avatar
    Christin Spoolstra

    “What if you could indeed lock eyes and hold yourself as truth was told, without looting, without running?” I was told once in high school that true humility was seeing yourself as you really are, no better and no worse. I’ve tried doing that over the years but often find myself running (distracting myself to avoid that self-conversation) or looting (finding fault with the situation/act but justifying myself in that moment – something I’ve done a lot in LoR).

    These few words hit me the hardest here: “I get it. I fight it. I get it.”

    I’ve been struggling with dealing with how things are (I get it.) while not stopping to fight for how they should be (I fight it.). But I’ve been weak on the latter.

    If I could really lock eyes with myself while truth was told, I think I’d find a weak, performative self. Someone who does want to understand, want to change, but is still always taking the easy road of avoidance. I’ve been learning here, yes, but where have I shared that except with those who have already been learning the same? I’ve been speaking of injustice, yes, but that has not translated into action. I’ve set myself a recurring asana task of completing a political act, but not once have I been able to mark it as complete.

    If I’m not running and not looting, I’ve been weighed, measured, and found wanting.

  7. Laura Berwick Avatar
    Laura Berwick

    I need to start practicing locking eyes. This metaphor is hitting me squarely, because I have a literal physical hard time looking people in the eyes, especially strangers, but even friends sometimes. And the feeling when I look away from even a friend’s face is, I’m realizing, very similar to the feeling when I read or hear the things I need to about racism, and I try to take them in, but I can’t process, so I look away.

    In that sense, I know I completely play out the easier to love in death idea. I do grieve, deeply, and am outraged at the death inflicted on black people for just doing regular things no white person would die for. I feel the things I think a caring, self-aware, trying-to-be-decent human should feel. But I don’t have to look the dead in the eye and love them alive and whole and complex. Which is what I need to do, every day, not just the days I read the news.

    Can I do it? Can I lock eyes and hold myself? If I can, can I process on a deeper level than my own anxiety and fears? I really don’t know. Yet. But I need to work toward that answer being YES. And that’s why I’m here.

    Affirming life by looking toward death makes every bit of sense to me now, especially in this context. There are so many things that prop me up that need to die to affirm life for everyone and especially black people. Maybe the death of me and my generation need to be part of the progression away from the centuries of horror and oppression. I want to do everything I can through my life to make equality happen, because I don’t want anyone to wait that long. But the institutions we need to dismantle do give me an edge, a survival advantage, and if working against that reduces my survival abilities, I need to step up and into that, against all “common sense” or deep-rooted biological impulses.

    There are a lot of films I need to see that won’t entertain me or offer escapist comfort. This one goes on the list. I feel like there’s a lot of navel gazing in this post. But it’s my navel that requires my inspection and correction. So I’ll work on my insides while I also try to work on my outsides.

  8. Deb Chymiak-Isanhart Avatar
    Deb Chymiak-Isanhart

    “It might feel like death, but it might also feel like rebirth.” Wow, that really resonates. Thank you. That reminder that death is not the end and a call to open to possibility.

  9. Vickie White Avatar
    Vickie White

    Wow, Lace. I want to read Carvell Wallace’s piece, but first I want to stay focused here and try to respond to your question. What if I could indeed lock eyes and hold myself as truth was told, without looting, without running? I think it might feel like death – death of illusions, lies, evasions, excuses; and maybe sorrow for lost ease that has been bought at the price of violence – but that it would be an act of love for other people for me to then confront that truth and try to change myself in response to it. It might feel like death but it might also feel like rebirth.

  10. Deb Chymiak-Isanhart Avatar
    Deb Chymiak-Isanhart

    Two parts continue to hold my thoughts.

    One is from Wallace,  “There is just one trick. It sometimes happens that to move toward love — true, active, life-affirming love — means to move toward death”.

    The other from Lace, “What if you could indeed lock eyes and hold yourself as truth was told, without looting, without running?”

    These feel very intertwined. I think one is required for the other. But, I’m not sure which comes first. Is it a willingness to step into transformation that allows a person to stand and hear full truth? Or is it that standing and hearing full truth transforms?

    Either way, this is a very powerful piece that I know I will come back to.

  11. Claire Ramsey Avatar
    Claire Ramsey

    Carvell Wallace is a fabulous writer w/a genuine clear voice. This article is not a “movie review,” even though quite a few NYT commenters think it is. Wallace is using the movie as a sounding chamber for delivering his message, which I take to be a message that white Americans need, over and over and over, to find ways to witness, believe, and even try to understand life “wedged in the narrow space between captivity and death — a spiritual state of being that many black people in America understand in our souls.” That description – the narrow space between captivity and death – expresses the reality of life for Black people in the US, in the past and now. And likely in the foreseeable future. I saw the headline of one review that called Queen & Slim “the back Bonnie and Clyde.” I haven’t seen Queen & Slim yet – it’s not playing in any of the movie houses close to me – but it does not look or sound anything like Bonnie and Clyde. A thoughtless comparison if you ask me. So what if I could lock eyes w/say, Lena Waithe, or Lace J Watkins or Portia or Leonie. . . would I be able to hold my emotions and hear their expressions of the truth? I immodestly like to think I would be able to hear it. I’ll see the film as soon as it comes near. And then I’ll let you know.

  12. Varda L Avatar
    Varda L

    The thing I’m learning about justice work in Black communities is how very, very much it is actively diminished, stunted, corralled, silenced in order to maintain systemic inequality. If white people would stop reflexively roadblocking every damn thing, maybe even work to provide a safety net against other white people, our society would make some big wins in a fairly short space. But that forces us to come to terms with the irrelevance of ourselves we created by insisting on all the terms and conditions, and learning on how to coast on others’ labor.

    I honestly don’t know how many white people are self-actualized enough to listen to truth and do anything positive with it. I know that I’m still counting it a win when I do no harm.

  13. Kathy Kratchmer Avatar
    Kathy Kratchmer

    “…how quickly the trajectory of a black life can change in a single interaction …”

    This reality pushes me forward. And knowing that, absent some great miracle,
    if the needle is to move at all in my community, in my lifetime, there’s really not a moment to be idle.

  14. Kathy Kratchmer Avatar
    Kathy Kratchmer

    What if?
    I will have learned to fully love, to listen and hear and better understand the one I have locked eyes with, totally undistracted by how/if what they are saying meshes with my experiences and understandings—- And why would that even be helpful once I no longer am motivated to ‘love’ only by a sense of affinity.

  15. Bree Schultz Cooper Avatar
    Bree Schultz Cooper

    I was sold when i saw the preview for this movie a couple weeks ago because everything Kaluuya touches is gold, and Lace’s essay is brilliant enough on its own, but Wallace’s review is unlike anything I’ve ever read. His evocative even soul-shattering descriptions of the experiences in the film make it impossible to finish reading without viscerally feeling the simultaneous love and sorrow and fear and vitality of what it could feel like to live the American black experience. Anyone who walks away from this article unchanged may not have a heartbeat…

    The realization that i have seen so many of the films mentioned in the review tells me I’ve been low-key on this path for a long time, but my being laid so open by the reminder of how quickly the trajectory of a black life can change in a single interaction tells me that, in spite of my conscious effort to do this work, I still have the privilege of forgetting between reminders. That i don’t walk in skin that renders me vulnerable every day.

  16. Lace Watkins Avatar
    Lace Watkins

    Be sure to read the comments on the NYT site as well. Not all are laudatory; but they are important, and in some cases, telling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *